ARCUS — Bridge Failure Research

ARCUS Atlas record

Viadotto Piano Carbone

This record concerns Viadotto Piano Carbone in Caltagirone. Recorded date: 8 May 2011. ARCUS outcome classification: TC. Recorded cause category: Unspecified. Reported trigger: No identifiable external trigger. Reported process: Other documented mode. Reported component: Multiple components. Recorded fatalities: 0; injuries: 0. Cause evidence: Probable.

Documentary notes and limitations

Section 3.7 of the ministerial report dated 22 October 2012 identifies foundation failure as the most probable hypothesis, with investigations then ongoing. Cause category and specific cause remain unspecified. It describes thirteen openings, masonry piers, plain-concrete arches and construction in the 1960s. Lack of reinforcement is a construction characteristic, not by itself evidence of deterioration or a causal defect. No specific supporting document is available for arch-crown deterioration or a causal sequence of infiltration and ground movement: those details are not assigned to this case. Findings on the different Feroleto–Marcellinara accident are not transferred. No immediate external trigger is identified. Demolition in 2014 is distinct from collapse in 2011; TC and multiple components are retained.

ARCUS ID
IT11.05.01
Date
2011-05-08
Municipality
Caltagirone
Province
Catania
Region
Sicilia
Coordinates
37.1732, 14.4712 · exact location
Crossing
Piano Carbone
Use
Railway
Severity
TC
Structural type
Arch bridge
Material
Plain concrete
Construction year
1960s
Cause category
Unspecified
Specific cause
Unspecified
Failure trigger
No identifiable external trigger
Failure process
Other documented mode
Component involved
Multiple components
Cause evidence
Probable
Source confidence
Medium
Victims
0
Injuries
0

Sources and scientific context (4)

  1. Ferrovia spezzata: pendolari da 6 anni senza treno (News · La7 · 2017-12-12)
  2. Demolizione totale del ponte ferroviario Caltagirone-Gela in provincia di Catania (Official/Technical · Ministero dell'Interno · 2014-10-07)
  3. Relazione d'indagine treno3793 Feroleto–Marcellinara — §3.7 precedente Piano Carbone8/5/2011 (Official/Technical · Ministero delle Infrastrutture e dei Trasporti · 2012-10-22)
  4. Interrogazione 4-01224 e risposta scritta — ponte ferroviario di Piano Carbone e ripristino della tratta Gela–Caltagirone (Official/Technical · Camera dei deputati — interrogazione Rizzo e altri, risposta del viceministro Riccardo Nencini · 2017-11-30)

Return to the Atlas · Propose a correction or new evidence