ARCUS — Bridge Failure Research

ARCUS Atlas record

Passerella sul Margorabbia

This record concerns Passerella sul Margorabbia in Germignaga. Recorded period: May 2002. ARCUS outcome classification: TC. Recorded cause category: Hydraulic. Reported trigger: Flood. Reported process: Scour. Reported component: Multiple components. Recorded fatalities: 0; injuries: 0. Cause evidence: Documented.

Documentary notes and limitations

The curator confirms a reinforced-concrete beam bridge from the supplied photograph. This visual identification of the main members does not come from S3 and does not establish prestressing, precise static system, support material or construction year. The 2006 CNR-IRPI/GNDCI monograph, page 4 and figure 4, documents central-pier failure and collapse of the Margorabbia pedestrian crossing in the 3–4 May 2002 episode. Stored 3 May starts that episode, not an established exact failure instant. The 2016 plan reproduces the same photographs rather than a second expert assessment; Mondiscia and Premaggio are the two sources' locality names, without a new survey. D'Angelo, Ballio and Ravazzani's S3 P100 reports 30 m, riverbed piers, pier and deck damage, TC, vertical erosion and no overtopping. Scour and multiple components retain that scientific provenance. Documented qualifies the published attribution, not an ARCUS forensic finding of exclusive causation. TC, zero casualties and the point are unchanged. The photograph is retained in the private archive only, without implied permission for public reuse. The classification in supplementary dataset S3 by D’Angelo, Ballio and Ravazzani (2025), record P100, is attributed to its authors and is not a new ARCUS measurement.

ARCUS ID
IT02.05.01
Date
2002-05-03
Municipality
Germignaga
Province
Varese
Region
Lombardia
Coordinates
45.9894, 8.7365 · exact location
Crossing
Margorabbia stream
Use
Cycle-pedestrian
Severity
TC
Structural type
Beam bridge
Material
Reinforced concrete
Cause category
Natural
Specific cause
Hydraulic
Failure trigger
Flood
Failure process
Scour
Component involved
Multiple components
Cause evidence
Documented
Source confidence
Medium
Victims
0
Injuries
0

Sources and scientific context (4)

  1. Bridge collapses in Italy across the 21st century: survey and statistical analysis (Scientific · Journal Paper · 2025-01-01)
  2. Piano di emergenza intercomunale: Margorabbia, maggio 2002 (Official/Technical · Protezione civile intercomunale, area Luino)
  3. Eventi di piena e frana in Italia settentrionale nel periodo 2002–2004 (Official/Technical · CNR-IRPI / Regione Piemonte)
  4. D'Angelo, Ballio & Ravazzani (2025) — Geomorphologic risk factors for river bridges, supplement S3 (Scientific · Journal Paper)

Return to the Atlas · Propose a correction or new evidence